An open letter to ORCA from Cate Cousland

Food for Thought …  What do you think?…

I started off writing a newspaper letter for ORCA members to have a read of but kept getting sidetracked wondering whether ORCA should be involved in any way in the November council elections in light of the massive challenges our society is facing. Normally I would prefer to be part of a non political group but local council seems to be the one form of government where the community can have a real chance to have a say and implement ideas locally. I understand that local government decisions can be thwarted by State and Federal Governments, but are we losing the chance to have a voice and actively push to make alternate energy projects a reality if we don’t get involved?

Should ORCA be putting up candidates or endorsing candidates?

Are there any members with the profile, skills and health who are prepared to stand?

Imagine the difference an informed council could make to the future of our town!!!

What do you think?

Letter re Apollo Bay Harbour Development  (unfinished)

The Colac Otway Shire has recently notified ratepayers of a 5 day ‘Enquiry by Design’ process to determine the future of the Apollo Bay harbour. Whilst at first glance this may appear a fitting conclusion to an ’18 year’ saga, on further reading the harbour proposal remains fundamentally flawed through the continued lack of consideration of the impact of climate change on the Apollo Bay coastline.

Scientific studies by the world Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the Australian CSIRO and the Victorian Coastal Spaces Council state unequivocably that climate change will have severe impacts on coastal areas. Increases in extreme weather, ranging from storm surges, king tides, violent windstorms, rising sea levels, higher sea temperatures and acidification of the ocean will produce significant impacts for coastal communities like Apollo Bay.

Coastal erosion, which is already occurring, will also impact on the viability of the Great Ocean Road as a transport and tourist route. The Victorian government has recently appealed for Commonwealth money to shift vulnerable seaside towns inland. As reported in the Age on 17/8/2008, the Brumby government has lodged a submission to a Federal House of Representatives inquiry into climate change and coastal communities, asking for financial support for a ‘retreat and protect’ strategy that could ‘minimise energy relief funds potentially required from the Federal government in the future.’

The submission also urges the Commonwealth to bolster emergency management planning and help alert coastal communities to climate change threats.

Before further ratepayers dollars and state government taxes are spent on the harbour project, perhaps the Colac Otway Shire council should address the following issues in relation to Apollo Bay.

The potential impact of climate change on Apollo Bay relative to its geographical and oceanic position.
Should development be moved to higher ground and the hills of Apollo Bay?  b

Whilst this might appear sacrilegious to those who have fought to keep the green hills surrounding the town, it may be a good long term option in order to maintain a safe township and a future tourist industry.

Provision of access to and from Apollo Bay.

At present there is no road into or out of Apollo Bay if the Barham River and Wild Dog Creek become impassable due to either flooding (as in 1923 and 1952) or through ocean inundation. This is of major concern for the potential safety of the community if an unexpected event occurs, as well as being of importance to the tourist industry if erosion, and consequent repair and inaccessibility, becomes an issue along the Great Ocean Road.

Future transport needs.

The impact of the decreasing availability and the increasing price of petrol on the community, and its impact on the future of the tourist industry, need to be assessed. Also the provision of basic transport between Apollo Bay and Colac.

Protection of water resources and arable land.

Natural resources in the Colac Otway shire including aquifers, rivers, estuaries and lakes should be assessed for protection and reservation for the benefit of present and future generations.

Viability of renewable energy options and first class sustainability measures.

How can council support clean energy options especially solar, wind and wave energy?  As well as helping the planet, both the tourist and building industries could benefit if Apollo Bay becomes a ‘showcase’ town known for its innovation and best practice.

The local government elections to be held in November 2008 will be of great significance to the future of our region if the councillors who are elected are prepared to……

  • represent the voters who elect them without fear or favour
  • seek information on climate change issues
  • actively support initiatives like renewable, clean energy options
  • work with the relevant authorities to protect and reserve water sources and arable land for the benefit of local food production and ecosystems
  • develop policies to aid drought stricken areas of the shire and prepare for the arrival of new pests as a result of global warming
  • work for shire voters in a similar way to Community Banks providing sound financial management while representing the wishes of the community
  • provide the community with the knowledge to make informed decisions for the future

Human Sign on Climate Change succeeds in bad weather

Congratulations to all who were involved in the Human Sign today (Monday 20th August 2008).

You are making difference!

There were considerable difficulties presented by wind, rain and clouds. Well done all the students at Apollo Bay and Elliminyt Primary in Colac who faced long waiting times while the plane found a way across the Ranges. Particularly well done the two Peters, Peter Bourne and Peter Geekie who did the organising. And big clap for Jeffrey Richardson who took the photos and for Tony McElvaney on the video camera. See Video of the sign.

Special thanks to Victor Bongiorno of Apollo Bay Aviation for braving the weather and supplying the plane. The central Victorian Climate Action Groups cancelled their signs as did the Surf Coast Shire Seems that nothing can stop people in the Otway Ranges.

John McConchie, Principal, Apollo Bay P-12 College says, ‘Each generation of students seems to face a defining issue. For my generation in the 60’s and 70’s it was the Vietnam War. Today young people are bombarded with frightening news about global warming and climate change. The Apollo Bay community is very environmentally sensitive and the never ending stream of negative information has a greater impact on young people than we realise. Giving students the opportunity to take positive action and creatively express their concerns is a very healthy process.’

Here are some of Jeffrey’s photos (reduced in resolution for the web):

Apollo Bay School \'Act Now\' from the air

Image#1. ‘Act Now!’ from the air formed by the students of Apollo Bay School

Act Now!  from the air but wider  - formed by the students of Apollo Bay School

Image#2. ‘Act Now!’ from the air but wider – formed by the students of Apollo Bay School

Act Now! from the air but wider again - formed by the students of Apollo Bay School

Image#3. ‘Act Now!’ from the air but wider again – formed by the students of Apollo Bay School

CO2!' from the air - formed by the students of Elliminyt Primary at Colac

Image#4. ‘CO2!’ from the air – formed by the students of Elliminyt Primary at Colac

CO2!' from the air but wder - formed by the students of Elliminyte Primary at Colac

CO2!’ from the air but wider – formed by the students of Elliminyt Primary at Colac

Email Simon Pockley or phone 0418575525 for high resolution copies of these images. Or, you can contact Jeffery Richardson: 0409 331 596

What’s next?

ORCA intends to hold a public forum on Friday evening 17th of October 2008 in order to identify practical local actions that the Otway community can take that will address the risks of damaging climate change. Professor John Sherwood of Deakin University will speak on the impact of climate change on the Otways.

28th July 2008: Solar Information Sessions Lorne

Solar power information sessions next Monday 28 July.

“The Solar Shop” will be running two information sessions on everything you need to know about solar electricity. Am I eligible for the $8,000 govt rebate? What’s involved in going solar? How much will I save? Which solar panels are best? How much does it cost? Energy saving tips. Also a 2 x free panel offer available on the day. Home, farm and business site visits to follow Tues 29th July. For further info call Aaron Lewtas 0402 931 872.

We have both a day time (Midday-1pm) and evening session (6-7pm) planned to suit those who might be working during the day. FREE

Hope to see you there & please RSVP to Fig Tree!

Cheers
Sue.

Sue Roberts
Coordinator
Lorne Fig Tree Community House
PO Box 207 Lorne VIC 3232
16 Mountjoy Pde
Ph: 03 5289 2972
Fax: 03 5289 2973
In office: Monday-Thursday

ORCA News 22nd July 2008

Coming events:

  1. 28th July Solar Information Session – Lorne
  2. August 20th – Human Sign (SCEG)
  3. 13th – 14th September 2008 Sustainable House Day
  4. 4th October 2008: Changing the Dream Symposium – Aireys Inlet
  5. October 11th – Otway Ranges Climate Change Action Forum (planned)
  6. January 20th to February 20th 2009 CO-EDAPT

The ORCA Newsletter is intended to keep you informed about Climate Change Actions in the Otways.

  • Less emails
  • Quick scans and digests
  • Ability to comment (talk back)
  • Easy to contribute and form discussion points

How to make a human sign

HOW TO MAKE A HUMAN SIGN

5th July

Human signs are great fun, relatively easy to do if you are organised. They generate a lot of conversation about climate change, engage your local community and most importantly stimulate action. Clean Energy for Eternity have now organised 35 human signs. Some have been better than others, and we have learnt a lot.

Here are a few of the things that we have learnt about making human signs.

If you want to make a human sign at school, three quarters of the work is already done. The most difficult thing about a human sign is advertising, generating the enthusiasm and getting the people there. To do a human sign in school hours means that you have a captive crowd on site with built in enthusiasm, in a safe monitored environment. All that remains is to decide what you are going to say, a group of helpers to spend 3 hours approx marking out the sign, approval from your principal, and a non political message.

You probably need at least 50 people per letter, so you should be able to work out how many letters you will be able to make for your word(s). 50 people standing in single file close together can make a very readable letter that is about 10 m high and 4 m wide. A gap of about 2m between each letter looks pretty good, and a gap of 10m between words is very readable. My advice would be to use block upper case letters and as the plane is taking its footage make the people, who are able too, crouch down for a more defined letter (this is especially important if you are located in tricky spots like the cross bar of an ‘A’). Smaller groups will have to use their ingenuity, one for example is providing an exclamation mark for its contribution as it has only 15 people total.

How to mark out the sign?

The first thing to do is to have a plan or map of the word(s) to spell out. Have all the dimensions carefully marked out. When you draw it to scale, you will get a pretty good idea of what it will look like from the air. The obvious place for a school sign would be on the school oval, or the closest safe open area available to the school.
In marking out the letters, the first thing to do is mark out the parallel tram tracks which can be done using a string line. If your letters are 10m high, make 2 parallel string lines on the oval 10 m apart. Then work out the centre point, and then mark out the letters, moving from the centre outwards. This will ensure that your sign is square and central within the oval. The easiest way to mark out the sign is with spray paint, the type builders use to mark out trenches etc (you use the can upside down). Dots of spray paint reasonably close together would not interfere with sports games the following weekend, and you will find that the paint will be gone in a few days or after the next mowing. The alternative is to use a lime marker, this also disappears in a day or 2, but is more difficult and time consuming to apply.

How to get people evenly spread throughout the sign?

You don’t want some letters thicker than others. Divide up the school population by the number of letters and this will give you an idea about how many students per letter. I would say that the best way for a school to form a sign would be to simply start at one end, and when each letter is tightly filled in single file, move onto the next letter. When you get to the end, you can distribute the remaining students into the sparser areas. Alternatively, you could assign different letters to different classes.

How to photograph the sign?

The only way to do this is from the air. The plane needs to have a high wing (ie a Cessna) and preferably fly with the door off, as this makes photography much easier. I would recommend both a still and video photographer, and the video camera should be broadcast quality (3 chip) so the sign can get on the TV. The camera needs to be high quality digital so the shot can get into the papers. The key with the photo (particularly if multiple signs are going to be pasted together to form a sentence) is to get the shot square, and from as close to directly above as possible. If multiple signs are being photographed, they should all be imaged (shot) from the same altitude. This is all relatively easy to organise, but CEFE can certainly help out if need be. We certainly have contacts ( after 5 signs) with aircraft pilots and photographers, if schools need help.

With multiple signs in a particular region, the cost of the plane could be shared between the schools involved. I would imagine that to film 4 schools from the air would cost about $300. That’s less than $100 per school. I am sure that a coin donation from the students involved would cover this cost. Check with us and other schools in the area to find out who is participating, co-ordinating exact times for the aerial shots is critical, you do not want to have your students waiting for too long.

Remember to video and photograph your sign taking shape from the ground, we have learnt that recording these signs provides a great source of footage for future use. You may decide as a school to put together a DVD of the event, I have watched dozens of times the DVD’s CEFE produced and still find my self looking for my kids and discovering people I did not know were involved.

It would be good to alert the media as soon as you have decided to participate, a short press release emailed and a few follow up phone calls has worked well for us. You never know, I wouldn’t be surprised if the ABC or other sent down their helicopter for the day. I would get onto Canberra times, Sydney Morning Herald, Illawarra Mercury, The Age, Win TV, etc and all the local papers. CEFE can help with contacts if you need help.

One final piece of advice. Someone will always be critical of the sign being filmed from the air ( as planes produce CO2). The way to pre-empt that criticism is to ‘offset’ the carbon emissions (CO2) for the flight. That is fairly easy to do. For 4 schools, a Cessna will burn approximately 40 litres of aviation fuel. There are several web sites that will be able to tell you how many trees need to be planted to offset the CO2 from the flight. It would probably amount to 1 or 2 trees being planted. Too easy. I would plant the tree(s) before the flight, and you then negate any potential criticism. The alternative is to pay for the offset in dollars, this would equate roughly to no more than $50 per flight max.

This is a great opportunity, will be good fun, will require a fair amount of work on the day, and will be a powerful statement. This will generate tens of thousands of discussions about climate change, and when people get talking, solutions start appearing. Your students will be proud to participate and add their voice to the growing concern for climate change.

Good luck
Matthew Nott
Clean Energy For Eternity